« Comments are basically broken. | Main | About as sexy as a severe case of salmonella. »

Nice. Real nice.

So here we are, six years out from 9/11, and not too many people seem to be giving a shit. This no longer surprises me, but there's a difference between adults choosing not to give a shit and adults deliberately keeping information from kids, whose lives will be forever colored by that very information. We are fucking doomed if this keeps up.

SALT LAKE CITY - Several Utah schools have decided to let Sept. 11, 2007 pass without observing the sixth anniversary of the unprecedented terror attacks against the United States -- over fear of re-kindling the haunting memories for those who vaguely remember them, or introducing them to children who weren't born yet.

This year, Sept. 11 falls on a Tuesday for the first since since the actual attacks. But some school administrators believe that commemorating the tragedy may inhibit the ability for students to make forward progress.

"We don't want our kids thinking about that. We want them to move on,'' said Beth Johnston, principal at East Layton Elementary in Davis County, whose oldest student was just 6 on Sept. 11, 2001. "It might be age-appropriate for older students to acknowledge and talk about it, but for our younger kids, we don't want them to dwell on violence."

Wouldn't want them to dwell on reality or anything. The thing is, you don't have to make it about "violence". I learned about WWII when I was about 6 years old and I'm pretty sure it wasn't taught to me in terms of how many bodies the Nazis incinerated daily at Auschwitz. I just knew that bad people do bad things, and you know what, I was OKAY. I was shockingly able to move on and make forward progress. Seriously. That principal's quote is some of the stupidest bullcorn I've ever heard.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.rachellucas.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/211

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Nice. Real nice.:

» add free url from add free url
adult url submit [Read More]

» rachel ray recipes from rachel ray recipes
rachel ray recipes [Read More]

Comments (9)

I happen to be one of those who thinks we don't see the footage often enough (or at all?) anymore. I know, it's hard, maybe cruel; especially re: the victim's families and survivors. But really. Wholesale denial? Isn't that how 9-11 happened in the first place? she asked, rhetorically.

I won't ever forget. But I also didn't want to relive it this morning on the news. I switched it to Nickelodean. I couldn't deal with it - I was so profoundly affected. It completely rocked my world and my way thinking about the world. I didn't even know the difference between Pakistan and Palestine. I was a useful idiot.

So, as an adult, I decide to not watch the news or the stories about the "Falling Man" being run now on the discovery channel (or one of those types of channels). But I'm an adult! I made that choice. And I'll never forget what happened.

But these kids need to know what happened. If we forget history...yada yada yada. I was learning about WWII and the death camps in elementary school. I met a death camp survivor in the 7th grade. Children can handle a lot more than adults give them credit for. It's cruel to try to keep reality from them, not helpful.

LabRat [TypeKey Profile Page]:

Pfffffttt. When I was a kid, my school (which was as preppie as they come) put up graphic photos of camp survivors- and not-so-survivors- in the school library to commemorate the Holocaust. This was the library used by everybody from grade 5 up.

We weren't traumatized, we got interested.

WayneB [TypeKey Profile Page]:

Let's see, I'm pretty sure I learned about the Holocaust watching war movies when I was under 10. Of course, that was when it wasn't a hate crime to play Cowboys and Indians, or line up your plastic toy soldiers and have a war with them. Heck, there's violence and death in Where The Red Fern Grows, and I read that before I was 12. So you don't give the younger kids graphic descriptions of the people jumping out the windows and hitting the pavement. That doesn't mean you can't do something.

I'll remember 9/11 and 9/12 together. On 9/12, my oldest son decided not to wait for his mother to get his younger brother from the other side of the school, and walked home with a friend of his instead. Of course, we didn't know this until later. What I knew when my wife called me at work was: a) There had been a shooting at the school (some crazy bitch had come and settled an argument with some crazy OLD bitch), b) everyone had been herded into the basement of said school, and c) my oldest boy was nowhere to be found. On the day after 9/11.

Needless to say, I didn't take long getting home. Since he turned out to be safe, we even decided not to kill him... 8-)

Mark [TypeKey Profile Page]:

I think school administrators must be certified cretins.

Ralph Gizzip [TypeKey Profile Page]:

As Misha would say, "Rope. Tree. Publik Skool Edjukater. Some assembly required."

"Anybody who doesn't know what's wrong with America's educational system never screwed an el-ed major."

-- P.J. O'Rourke

BarSinister [TypeKey Profile Page]:

When I was 10 yrs old, my father was on occupation duty in Germany. Over my mother's objections, he took me to see the camp at Dachau. The place had been cleaned up a bit, but not yet turned into a memorial. Dad wanted me to understand what had happened in Nazi Germany. I understood, alright, and never forgot. There were still ashes in the ovens and the smell of death still lingered.

I'm from Utah, and I can honestly say that this is just Davis/Salt Lake County liberal bullhonkey. I know that means nothing to most people, but to me it totally explains everything.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on September 11, 2007 9:11 AM.

The previous post in this blog was Comments are basically broken..

The next post in this blog is About as sexy as a severe case of salmonella..

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.